Quotable: Rebecca Solnit on “Leftsplaining”

Share

I’m going to share this without judgement. It’s hotly circulating on twitter and beyond. Whether you like the message or not, this post’s popularity makes it required reading for all Americans left of center on the political spectrum.

“…O rancid sector of the far left, please stop your grousing! Compared to you, Eeyore sounds like a Teletubby. If I gave you a pony, you would not only be furious that not everyone has a pony, but you would pick on the pony for not being radical enough until it wept big, sad, hot pony tears. Because what we’re talking about here is not an analysis, a strategy, or a cosmology, but an attitude, and one that is poisoning us. Not just me, but you, us, and our possibilities.

Leftists Explain Things to Me

The poison often emerges around electoral politics. Look, Obama does bad things and I deplore them, though not with a lot of fuss, since they’re hardly a surprise. He sometimes also does not-bad things, and I sometimes mention them in passing, and mentioning them does not negate the reality of the bad things.

The same has been true of other politicians: the recent governor of my state, Arnold Schwarzenegger, was in some respects quite good on climate change. Yet it was impossible for me to say so to a radical without receiving an earful about all the other ways in which Schwarzenegger was terrible, as if the speaker had a news scoop, as if he or she thought I had been living under a rock, as if the presence of bad things made the existence of good ones irrelevant….”

I found this in Mother Jones where it was called “Stop Leftsplaining! ” but it originally appeared at TomDispatch where it was entitled “The Rain on Our Parade”. Go there to read the whole thing.

Share

Leave a comment!